Even amidst the Maoist era’s politicized cultural production, culture workers continued to adapt traditional theatre to create bold new statements


Resisting Spirits is a reconsideration of the significance and periodization of literary production in the high socialist era, roughly 1953 through 1966, specifically focused on Mao-era culture workers’ experiments with ghosts and ghost plays. Maggie Greene combines rare manuscript materials—such as theatre troupes’ annotated practice scripts—with archival documents, memoirs, newspapers, and films to track key debates over the direction of socialist aesthetics. Through arguments over the role of ghosts in literature, Greene illuminates the ways in which culture workers were able to make space for aesthetic innovation and contestation both despite and because of the constantly shifting political demands of the Mao era. Ghosts were caught up in the broader discourse of superstition, modernization, and China’s social and cultural future. Yet, as Greene demonstrates, the ramifications of those concerns as manifested in the actual craft of writing and performing plays led to further debates in the realm of literature itself: If we remove the ghost from a ghost play, does it remain a ghost play? Does it lose its artistic value, its didactic value, or both? At the heart of Greene’s intervention is “just reading”: the book regards literature first as literature, rather than searching immediately for its political subtext, and the voices of dramatists themselves finally upstage those of Mao’s inner circle. Ironically, this surface reading reveals layers of history that scholars of the Mao era have often ignored, including the ways in which social relations and artistic commitments continued to inform the world of art. Focusing on these concerns points to continuities and ruptures in the cultural history of modern China beyond the bounds of “campaign time.” Resisting Spirits thus illuminates the origins of more famous literary inquisitions, including that surrounding Hai Rui Dismissed from Office, by exploring ghost plays such as Li Huiniang that at first appear more innocent. To the contrary, Greene shows how the arguments surrounding ghost plays and the fates of their authors place the origins of the Cultural Revolution several years earlier, with a radical new shift in the discourse of theatre.

Maggie Greene is Assistant Professor of History at Montana State University.

"Meticulously researched, elegantly composed, thought-provoking, and critically engaging, Resisting Spirits is a must-read for anyone interested in Chinese theatre and dramatic literature, the cultural history of the PRC, Chinese modernism, and art and politics in general."

- Xing Fan

"The volume makes an important contribution to questions of historical periodization as regards the PRC's transition from a revolutionary to a post-revolutionary society. Moreover, on account of the selected case studies, Greene's book effectively foregrounds ghost opera as having played a major role not only in determining the direction of drama reform in the mid-twentieth century, but also, albeit indirectly, in contributing to the radicalization of the political atmosphere in the run-up to the Cultural Revolution." 

- Letizia Fusini

Read: Reviewed in Theatre Journal | March 2021